Board Thread:Monster Discussions/@comment-25246220-20141012143221/@comment-24277243-20141014143835

The 2014 film, end of story.

Like ProvenBeat said, the 1956 film is just an American edit that inserted scenes with Raymond Burr, the original Japanese footage is still intact, so it's still (technically) a Japanese film.

Seeing how the 1998 movie isn't really considered a Godzilla film, it doesn't count.

The 2014 reboot wins by a landslide. Almost everything in it is made by Americans. So that makes it a 'Murica movie.