User blog comment:Cloverfield monster/My attempt at a Godzilla YTP./@comment-3367060-20140920011340

Uh, sorry to be this honest, but this isn't very good, and I'll explain why.

Firstly, YouTube Poops haven't been like this since 2007. This is what you would call a "SpaDinner" poop, which are very bad and low quality and don't take much effort to make. If you want to see what YouTube Poops look like now, in the current YouTube, I would recommend watching this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Gvr-6gR4Ww

YTPs need to mix things up and make it unpredictable and funny. Scientifically speaking, when something completely different from what someone would expect shows up, they're likely to laugh (but it must be funny, it can't just be a random cutaway). Here are some "poopisms" that should be avoided at all costs (some of which are prevalent in your video):
 * Long periods of unedited content from the source material are boring. Obviously, if someone is watching this video, they're bored. However, if they get THAT bored, they'll leave immediately.
 * You have to actually edit. Sentence mix. Get the character to say what you want them to say with their own voices by remixing some of their other dialogue. Just plopping in something that obviously isn't their voice will make you look lazy and will severely detract from the quality of the poop.
 * YouTube Poops are NOT just taking something and shoving memes up its butt. Only relying on memes and not actual jokes will make the poop look very bad.

Your "YTP" was mostly just unedited clips of Godzilla 2014 with random memes thrown in, an overwhelming majority of which fail. The reason that the "people from Godzilla-Movies.com" might've liked it is because they haven't seen YTPs ever before (or they haven't seen quality YouTube Poops before), therefore, like people who see today's quote unquote "parody" movies think that the parody movies are clever when in reality they're very, very bad movies that fail on several cinematic levels.

Some of the things that actually made me smile about your poop are: Gareth Edwards with a troll face and the TROLOLO song. That was actually funny! But don't repeat that; instead, use that as a place to think of more jokes!